Why Should Delaware Care?
Delawareโ€™s hospitals are powerful and often consolidated entities. For decades, each of the stateโ€™s three main hospital systems have remained largely within their bounds by county line. But as more retirees flock to the stateโ€™s southernmost county, those boundaries are being disregarded. 

A board of Delaware hospital regulators denied two proposed ChristianaCare campuses in Kent and Sussex counties Tuesday, marking the latest turn in what has been a months-long feud between the upstate healthcare giant and multiple hospital systems below the C&D Canal.ย 

The Delaware Health Resources Board, tasked with weighing the cost-benefit analysis for the public in major hospital expansions, questioned data presented by ChristianaCare supporting its two proposed โ€œmicrohospitalsโ€ in Georgetown and Camden. Board members ultimately voted against both proposals, which would have brought multiple emergency care beds to the stateโ€™s lower counties.ย 

Tuesdayโ€™s vote represents a major loss for ChristianaCare, which had planned to spend more than $123 million on the campuses and has been targeting further expansion deeper into southern Delaware. 

In a statement following the vote, ChristianaCare CEO Jenn Schwartz said the hospital was โ€œextremely disappointedโ€ with the boardโ€™s decision and that it would โ€œcarefully review the decision and evaluate our options.โ€ 

She added that families in Kent and Sussex counties have asked for more services closer to their homes, and ChristianaCareโ€™s proposals worked to address gaps in care. 

โ€œEach service included in the thoughtful system of care outlined in our proposal is designed to meet the needs of the growing, aging communities in Kent and Sussex counties,โ€ Schwartz said in a statement. โ€œHealthcare is changing, and we need to develop innovative new ways of providing care for Delawareans who need it.โ€

But the vote also represents a win for Delawareโ€™s other major hospital systems, who had pushed back against these proposals fiercely in a rare public dispute between the powerful institutions. 

Bayhealth, the stateโ€™s second largest hospital system, said it appreciated the boardโ€™s decision. CEO Terry Murphy said in a statement the facilities would have added โ€œhigh-cost servicesโ€ to the area and made healthcare โ€œmore unaffordable than it is today.โ€

โ€œWe believe improving healthcare access requires balancing access, quality and affordability,โ€ Murphy said. โ€œBayhealth welcomes competition and supports expanding outpatient services, but we do not believe adding small hospitals is the best approach for our communities.โ€

What happened at the meeting?

ChristianaCare officials opened the meeting with a presentation where they outlined an argument as to why Sussex and Kent counties were in need of its two facilities. During that presentation, ChristianaCare representatives also said they would only move forward with the project if both campuses are approved. 

This caused some concern among board members who questioned what would happen if they denied one project but not the other. 

The hospital then fielded questions from board members who challenged the hospitalโ€™s presentation. Board members asked about transportation agreements between nearby hospital systems, potential treatment delays and alleged data discrepancies . 

Many of the concerns were from board members who struggled to reconcile data presented to them on Tuesday with information included in the hospitalโ€™s initial application. 

John Hundley, chief operating officer at Westside Family Healthcare, said he struggled to understand data presented by ChristianaCare about how many emergency department visits the two facilities would bring. 

Hundley homed in on data he interpreted as showing the Camden facility expecting 3.6 million visits a year for a county with less than 200,000 residents. ChristianaCare representatives said those figures were not correct and they were not intended to be interpreted as such. 

Still, he said the discrepancy had an impact on his vote.

โ€œI’m kind of a numbers guy, and when they don’t add up, it’s like pulling the one straw and everything kind of falls apart,โ€ Hundley said.

The board was then required to vote on each of the proposals individually.

One board member suggested tabling the vote to give ChristianaCare a chance to address the boardโ€™s many questions, but that motion failed. 

For the Camden campus, board members voted 8-1 with two abstentions to deny the proposal. The Georgetown proposal also met a similar fate with an 8-1 vote against the proposal.ย 

What was ChristianaCare hoping to build?

For the better part of two years, ChristianaCare has spent millions on an expansion blitz. It has proposed and opened sites in Pennsylvania, further entrenched itself in New Castle County, and has begun to reach farther south. 

In February, ChristianaCare announced that its first major downstate campus would be a $65 million healthcare facility in Georgetown.

In May, the hospital also announced it would open a $58.1 million health campus in Camden, continuing its push into contested downstate markets.

The 38,000โ€‘squareโ€‘foot ChristianaCare Camden campus would have opened about a mile from the Walmart on U.S. Route 13. The state healthcare giant said in a statement the new campus would have offered emergency and inpatient beds, as well as primary care and outpatient services.

It hoped to open the facility by 2029.

ChristianaCare also said the new facility would bring 83 new jobs. As it has done with other recently announced ventures, ChristianaCare positioned its expansion as a means of supporting Delawareโ€™s growing and aging population.

The healthcare system also expected its Georgetown facility to open by 2029. It would have offered emergency beds, behavioral, specialty and primary care on U.S. Route 113, just south of the Bridgeville Road intersection.

Downstate hospitals challenge proposals

For months, ChristianaCare’s proposals have found themselves scrutinized by competing hospitals in the region, who say the campuses may not be permitted under current Delaware law and would not benefit the healthcare ecosystem at large.

The lower counties have long been considered outside of ChristianaCareโ€™s regional grip, but ChristianaCare said it believes the new campuses would bring more emergency care to Kent and Sussex counties as the state continues to age and faces access shortages. 

Delawareโ€™s downstate hospitals โ€” which included Bayhealth in Dover, TidalHealth in Seaford and Beebe Healthcare in Lewes โ€” challenged ChristianaCareโ€™s reasoning, saying the new facilities could make emergency care more expensive for patients.

At a public meeting in October, hospital leaders also said the projects, dubbed โ€œmicrohospitals,โ€ lack a regulatory definition under Delaware law and may run afoul of another law signed this summer meant to curb the involvement of for-profit enterprise in nonprofit healthcare.

The feud began in late August after Bayhealth submitted a letter to the Health Resources Board, asking regulators to pull the projects. Beebe and TidalHealth soon followed Bayhealth, submitting similar letters. 

All three formed the unified coalition as market share, especially in southern Delaware, becomes more valuable to healthcare providers.

Downstate arms race

For decades, Delawareโ€™s three major health care systems largely fit into geographic monopolies: ChristianaCare serving New Castle County, Bayhealth serving Kent County and Beebe Healthcare in coastal Sussex County.

But over the last five years, a health care arms race has heated up between Bayhealth, Beebe and now TidalHealth, coming up from Salisbury, Maryland. They have all built or broken ground on major projects in locations such as Lewes, Milton or Millsboro in recent years.

It follows a post-COVID population boom in Sussex County. The region is now designated as a โ€œMedically Underserved Areaโ€ by the federal government, with projections showing that the population will increase from 237,000 in 2022 to more than 361,000 by 2050. The county is also rapidly graying, as the population growth is largely driven by retirees who will demand more healthcare needs.

The arrival of ChristianaCare, which to date only had primary care offices in Milford and Rehoboth Beach, will bring needed resources, but also new competition to the crowded market.

In 2019, the Health Resources Board was central in a debate over whether to allow Beebe to build a freestanding emergency room in Georgetown. It ultimately denied that project, saying it was too close to Bayhealthโ€™s Milford campus and Nanticoke Hospital in Seaford.

The board was also expected to be critical of Bayhealthโ€™s plans to build its own freestanding emergency room in Milton, which led the Dover-based health system to pull its plans.

Both of those projects, however, predated the population surge that has particularly struck Sussex County after the COVID housing market boom.

Nick Stonesifer graduated from Pennsylvania State University, where he was the editor in chief of the student-run, independent newspaper, The Daily Collegian. Have a question or feedback? Contact Nick...