The Vibe Check: Fifty Nine
Concept: Elevated, globally influenced cuisine served in an intimate, contemporary setting
Average entrรฉe price: $28, ranging from $16 to $42
Kids’ menu? No, but the kitchen can accommodate young diners
Alcohol? Yes, full bar, with an emphasis on distinctive wines and creative cocktails
Vegetarian-friendly? Yes, the Soil section offers thoughtfully prepared vegetable dishes, including vegan options
Gluten-friendly? Yes, numerous gluten-free options, including dishes that can be modified
Live music? Not currently, but occasional jazz or blues performances are planned
Hours: Wed.-Sat., 5 p.m.-10 p.m., Sun.-Tues. closed
Address: 59 Baltimore Ave., Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971
Website: fiftyninerehoboth.com

David Kneller is nothing if not tenacious. 

For instance, he is determined to create the perfect foie gras dish. Heโ€™s been experimenting with the luxurious ingredient for so long that he keeps a list of the recipes. 

โ€œIt has been one of my personal chef challenges from day one,โ€ said Kneller, co-owner of Fifty Nine, the 36-seat restaurant in Rehoboth Beach.

Diners might say he nailed the latest version: serpentine loops of piped peach-colored foie gras on a canvas of tomato-apricot jam.

Fifty Nine’s foie gras ganache of tomato apricot jam, thyme Madeline’s, brown butter milk crumble and mustard seed. | SPOTLIGHT DELAWARE PHOTO BY PAM GEORGE

The creation is the perfect balance of flavors and textures. The jam, mustard seed and madeleines โ€” made with thyme โ€” introduce just the right amount of savoriness to offset the sweetness, while a brown-butter milk crumble adds a pleasing crunch.

The dish didnโ€™t come together overnight. After finding the right ingredients, Kneller sketched the presentation before committing it to the plate.

โ€œIt was probably two or three times before we got the design we really like,โ€ he said.

Chef David Kneller. | PHOTO COURTESY OF FIFTY NINE

Kneller needed the same determination to open Fifty Nine and its adjoining business, The Market at 59, which sells house-made breads, sandwiches, prepared meals, cheeses and specialty pantry items.

The chef and his business partners persevered after his best friend, David Kuzio, died from injuries sustained in a car accident on Feb. 2, 2024 โ€” the day after they signed the lease. Kuzio, a fellow chef, was a key collaborator on the project.

Then came two and a half years of permitting and construction delays and unexpected expenses. The building had 22 rooms, one functioning bathroom and no commercial kitchen.

Without major financial backers, the partners had to stretch their resources, Kneller said. The Market at 59 opened on March 19, 2026, Kuzioโ€™s birthday. Fifty Nine followed on Aug. 13.

โ€œIโ€™m so proud of what weโ€™ve built,โ€ Kneller said.

Pursuing a Dream

Kneller, who grew up in Greensboro, Maryland, on the Eastern Shore, met Kuzio when they both worked at Bas Rouge and The Stewart in Easton, owned by Bluepoint Hospitality.

They chatted about opening a large gourmet market with a bar and casual dining area. The inspiration was Aimee Olexyโ€™s Talulaโ€™s Daily in Philadelphia, which combines a specialty food market with on-site dining.

It was just what Rehoboth Beach needed, they agreed. So did Rushabh Maniar, co-owner of Camden Cigars and Camden Liquor & Wine in Camden, Delaware, and his brother, Kahan Maniar, friends who became business partners.

Fifty Nine’s Elysian Fields lamb loin with cauliflower puree, kale salad, Spanish olive, pickled red onion and pomegranate. | PHOTO BY MEGHAN FITZGERALD, COURTESY OF FIFTY NINE

They leased the former Mark Showell Interiors showroom at the corner of Baltimore Avenue and Second Street. But the 4,185-square-foot buildingโ€™s occupancy and fire-safety requirements threatened to add $220,000 for a sprinkler system to the costs, Kneller said.

To avoid the expense, the partners divided the building with a fire-rated wall, creating two separate spaces โ€” and businesses โ€” with different occupancy limits.

The solution accelerated plans for Fifty Nine.

A Shadow Box for Flavor

The restaurantโ€™s minimalist dรฉcor includes a black-and-white palette and clean lines. The ambiance is decidedly contemporary. Cylindrical cordless table lamps with illuminated bands look sleek on black tables with black chairs. But the plates, including those from Crate & Barrel, are white.

Fifty Nine’s cheesecake with compressed peaches, corn crumble and white chocolate ganache. | PHOTO COURTESY OF FIFTY NINE

Knellerโ€™s attention to detail reflects his experience at Grace, the former three-Michelin-star restaurant in Chicago helmed by chef Curtis Duffy. Grace had a different garnish for each menu item. While thatโ€™s not cost-efficient at Fifty Nine, Kneller still believes that each composed dish should be a thing of beauty.

The menu is divided into categories: Bites, Land, Sea, Soil and Dessert.

Bites include fire-roasted olives with Fresno chili peppers, tasty nibbles to share over cocktails.

Just donโ€™t ask for Titoโ€™s Handmade Vodka. Instead, servers may recommend Etesia Vodka, a wheat-based vodka produced by Don Ciccio & Figli in Washington, D.C.

โ€œWe want to try supporting small family companies,โ€ Kneller said.

The Land section features meats, such as Elysian Field lamb loin perched on frilly kale and a bed of cauliflower puree.

Kneller originally planned to serve house-made salt-and-vinegar fingerling potato chips with beef tartare, but a beautiful piece of tuna changed his mind. The rosy chunks come with mildly bitter Castelfranco lettuce with cream-colored leaves and burgundy marbling.

Diners are encouraged to make lettuce wraps with the fish and chips. 

โ€œI want people to use their hands, get dirty, have fun,โ€ Kneller said.

Many people have used buttery hamachi, a Japanese yellowtail, in sushi, sashimi or crudo. 

Fifty Nine’s tuna tartare with smoky ponzu, salt-and-vinegar fingerling potato chips and castelfranco. | PHOTO COURTESY OF FIFTY NINE

โ€œNobody would ever cook this fish,โ€ Kneller said. โ€œI was like, โ€˜This is so incredible.โ€™ I was like, โ€˜Letโ€™s cook it!โ€™โ€

He sears the fish to golden brown on one side and serves it with Mandarin orange beurre blanc and black cardamom meringue. He thinks Kuzio would approve. 

โ€œWe donโ€™t do the norm,โ€ he said.

Seared scallops rest in a reddish-brown โ€˜nduja sauce inspired by a rockfish dish Kneller and chef de cuisine Chris Ferrell prepared for a culinary competition. The Italian sausage is cooked with shallots and garlic, then combined with an anise-flavored liqueur, a splash of cream and a touch of blue cheese. The result is a rich, savory counterpoint to the sweet scallops.

In the Zone

The magic happens in the kitchen, visible through a glass door on Baltimore Avenue. Between the market and restaurant, the space stays busy.

The first employee arrives at 4 a.m. to begin bread production, while pastry chefs start on the desserts that need to set. Employees come and go throughout the day, and the last person may leave at 1 a.m. or later.

Kneller encourages flexible schedules, believing that staff can adjust their hours to the workload. The mood in the kitchen is genial.

Chef David Kneller, second from right, poses for a group shot with Fifty Nine team members. | PHOTO COURTESY OF FIFTY NINE

โ€œThe thing I love about David is that his talent far outweighs his ego, which is unusual for most chefs,โ€ said Missi Moore, founder of Egg, who invited Kneller to do pop-up events in her breakfast/lunch restaurant when his kitchen was under construction. โ€œHeโ€™s humble and gracious.โ€

Fifty Nine is not all about technique and presentation. Recently, a customer ordered oeufs en meurette, a classic French dish featuring a poached egg in a rich red-wine sauce. Afterward, he told Zelie, Knellerโ€™s wife, that it reminded him of his grandmotherโ€™s cooking and childhood. She returned to the kitchen with tears in her eyes, moved by the customer’s reaction.

Zelie works at the restaurant and market when sheโ€™s not teaching kindergarteners. Itโ€™s her first foray into hospitality, and itโ€™s given her the chance to see into her husbandโ€™s profession. 

โ€œI really donโ€™t know how his amazing brain works. He truly is an artist,โ€ she said.

The creativity extends to promotions to attract locals. On Wednesdays, the restaurant features โ€œUnbuttoned,โ€ a casual menu with burgers, fried chicken and Wagyu pigs in a blanket. Servers trade their usual attire for concert T-shirts, the music gets more upbeat and guests can have a burger and a Pabst Blue Ribbon. The regular menu returns Thursday through Saturday.

Kneller is currently working on a coffee-and-tea shop in the Cultured Pearlโ€™s building in Rehoboth. Heโ€™d also like to start a wholesale bread business.

Meanwhile, heโ€™s continuing to refine Fifty Nine and The Market at 59, the two businesses that required so much resilience to open.

โ€œHeโ€™s very tenacious, with a youthful energy I wish I had,โ€ Moore said of the 36-year-old chef.

For Kneller, who serves โ€œKuzioโ€™s Meatballsโ€ in the market, the drive goes beyond ambition. Itโ€™s a tribute to a friend.

โ€œThis is a passion project,โ€ Kneller said.