Why Should Delaware Care? 
While much of the consequential decision-making for county governments plays out publicly in the form of public hearings and ordinance discussions, the day-to-day experiences of county employees are more shielded from public view. A Kent County employee’s racial discrimination lawsuit provides insight into those inner workings and alleged unfair treatment. 

A former Kent County employee is suing the local government for racial discrimination, claiming she was underpaid, not allowed to work remotely and suffered retaliation after raising objections. 

Aleyshia Young served as the Kent County Chief Deputy Register of Wills until resigning in June. She filed the lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for Delaware on Aug. 11.

In the complaint, Young, a Black woman, alleges she was discriminated against by the county in a series of incidents between January 2025 and June 2026, which amounted to her being paid substantially less than her white counterparts and targeted with stricter work requirements after raising the payment concerns with county officials. 

In response, the county filed a motion to dismiss Young’s lawsuit, arguing the claims are “long on accusations but short on facts” to prove discrimination or retaliation. The motion also asserts that federal law does not prohibit disagreements about compensation or workplace fairness, but instead prohibits “employment actions taken because of race and retaliation.”  

“The complaint fails to plausibly allege either,” the county’s response states.

Young’s lawsuit is not the first time Kent County has faced legal challenges and claims of unfair treatment by a former county employee in recent years. In early 2025, former county administrator Ken Decker received a roughly $350,000 settlement after he was fired from his position for reporting a conflict of interest with a Levy Court commissioner to a state board. 

In an interview with Spotlight Delaware, Young also claimed her experience is indicative of the challenges faced by non-white county employees. She said some stay at jobs where they are being treated unfairly because of a lack of alternatives in Kent County. 

“Lots of people have complaints,” Young said. “But they just won’t do anything. They put their head down and keep working.” 

Kent County officials declined to comment on the litigation, beyond the motion to dismiss.  

Levy Court President Joanne Masten told Spotlight Delaware she “had no idea” about the lawsuit, and hearing news of it left her “tongue tied.” 

Following the county’s motion to dismiss, Young, who is representing herself and is a licensed attorney in Guam, filed a response, redoubling her argument that she has a “well-pleaded factual allegation.”  

The county, through its attorney Scott Wilcox, then filed a counter response. U.S. District Court Judge Sherry Fallon has not yet ruled on the motion to dismiss.

Asked why she is representing herself instead of retaining an attorney, Young said she could not find someone under the time constraints willing to take on her case. 

The difficulty of finding an attorney for discrimination cases is not uncommon in Delaware, according to Pat Gallagher, a Wilmington-based employment attorney. 

“It is hard for any plaintiff to get the outcome they’re seeking,” Gallagher said. “But it is particularly hard for employment and civil rights.” 

Salary claims 

Young was working as the county’s Deputy Register of Wills for roughly two years when she was promoted in March 2025 to Chief Deputy, the top staff position in an office tasked with handling the legal administration of deceased people’s estates.

That is when her compensation issues began, she said. 

During her time working for Kent County, Aleyshia Young was promoted from deputy register of wills to chief deputy register of wills, the office’s top staff position. | PHOTO COURTESY OF ALEYSHIA YOUNG

She said she was paid less than her predecessor who had fewer qualifications; received substantially smaller pay increases than white county employees, and was not compensated for additional duties she performed while the deputy position was vacant.

In a legal response, Wilcox, the county’s attorney, described Young as repeatedly characterizing “ordinary employment decisions,” as discriminatory. 

They were not, in fact, related to race, he said.

Young said she was given the lowest salary in the pay range for the position at $55,000, while her white female predecessor was being paid $66,705 before she left the role. Young also has a law degree and years of legal experience, while she claimed her predecessor had a high school diploma and no prior applicable experience. 

“I anticipated that I would make as much as she was making, at least, which at that time was $12,000 or $14,000 more than I was making,” Young told Spotlight Delaware. 

Despite what Young described as requests by herself and the elected Register of Wills, DJ Cox, to county leaders for her to receive a raise, they declined and kept her salary at $55,000. 

Cox, who was elected to lead the department in January 2025, said pay decisions were at the discretion of the county HR department, but Young was “a good employee,” who he “still supports.”

Young cited examples of other Kent County employees who received raises in her lawsuit, including white clerks in her office and other white county employees like the county administrator and director of finance, who were given substantially higher raises when they stepped into new roles or filled in extra duties for a vacant position. 

She also said the salaries of her chief deputy counterparts in New Castle and Sussex counties, who were paid $98,476 and $85,333, respectively, are evidence that her role was in too low of a pay category. 

County leaders, however, said Young was compensated appropriately for her role, and the circumstances for other county employees’ pay increases were different. 

Wilcox wrote in court documents that Young’s salary comparisons to these other employees are not relevant, because she compared herself to “employees occupying fundamentally different positions.” 

Levy Court Vice President Bob Scott also told Spotlight Delaware the examples are not applicable, because Kent County pays less than the other two counties in “every position.”

A current Kent County employee, who is also a person of color, said she has learned over time that county leaders “don’t seem open at all” to increasing the pay of some county employees. 

“If [Young] were a white male or white female who was an attorney, there wouldn’t have been any issue whatsoever,” the employee, who spoke under the condition of anonymity for fear of retribution, said. “She would have gotten a salary to exceed what the previous chief deputy was compensated for.”

Remote work, employee policy changes 

While Young said she was frustrated by her salary disparity, “all of the other racism started to trickle its way in,” in the months following her unsuccessful ask for a pay increase. 

This racism, she said, included county leaders not allowing her to have a flexible remote work schedule, or bring her young son into work for a couple of hours a day, while other county employees were afforded such flexibility. 

Young said she had received approval from Cox, her supervisor, to work from home when necessary, but County Administrator Kevin Sipple and Human Resources Director Trudy Horsey told her she had to sign a contract outlining when she was allowed to work remotely. She claimed her white predecessor and other employees at a similar level never had to sign such a contract.

Following a meeting in early 2026 about the remote work contract, Young said another county employee at the meeting told her they were glad they “did not have her skin color.”

Ultimately, Young did not sign the remote work contract because Wilcox, the county attorney, said it was not necessary.

The Kent County Levy Court seal. | SPOTLIGHT DELAWARE PHOTO BY MAGGIE REYNOLDS

Young filed a racial discrimination charge with the Equal Employment Opportunities Commission (EEOC), the federal body that investigates discrimination complaints, in February 2026 about the pay disparity and remote work situation. Submitting a complaint to the commission is required as the first step in the process of filing an employment discrimination lawsuit. 

Young also alleges the county retaliated against her filing an EEOC complaint by making changes to the county’s employee policy handbook specifically targeted at her position after they were notified of her complaint. 

She said the county changed the code to read “may be” instead of “shall be” in a section about whether Deputy and Chief Deputy employees would be afforded certain employee benefits, leaving more of her benefits up to the discretion of Levy Court commissioners. 

Wilcox disputed the handbook change amounted to retaliation against Young, as the Levy Court did not vote to approve it until after Young had resigned from her position in June. He wrote in the motion to dismiss the lawsuit that the “temporal proximity,” or the time frame of just a few days between Young’s resignation and the adoption of the policy changes, is not enough evidence to “establish causation.” 

Young said the county delayed implementing the policy until after she resigned as a “strategic move,” so they could deny they had retaliated against her. 

Broader environment 

Young said she believes her experience is not uncommon in the largely white, male dominated Kent County government. Still, she said, it is difficult to speak out and risk retaliation. 

“I had no intention of leaving,” she said. ‘But I’m not going to stay here and be underpaid and disrespected and mistreated.” 

But experts said the employment discrimination claim process can be a long, arduous one.

Young said she contacted a couple of lawyers to represent her after she received a “Right to Sue” letter from the EEOC. 

The lawyers were hesitant to take on the case, Young said, because the EEOC requires a person file their employment discrimination lawsuit within 90 days of receiving their letter. The attorneys told her there was not enough time for them to get a good grasp on the facts of the case.

The EEOC received 123 race-based discrimination claims in Delaware in 2025. The commission’s database does not list how many of those claims were sustained over that same time period. 

Gallagher, the employment attorney, said he advises people to find an attorney before they file an EEOC complaint, because the 90-day window to locate a lawyer and file a lawsuit is too short. 

He added there are only a few lawyers who represent plaintiffs in employment discrimination cases in Delaware, which makes it much harder for an individual to find and afford a lawyer. 

With or without an attorney, the legal process for a plaintiff in an employment discrimination lawsuit involves withstanding the employer’s attempts to dismiss the case — as Kent County has attempted to do — followed by discovery, or the attorneys’ information gathering phase, before the possibility of a settlement is discussed.

“The standard is unique in American law that there is a burden shifting framework the plaintiff has to survive,” Gallagher said. “It gives a lot of subjectivity to the judge and a higher percentage of employment discrimination cases get lost.”

It remains to be seen whether the district court will grant Kent County’s motion to dismiss Young’s claims or allow her case to proceed. 

Young said she is committed to seeing her claims through, regardless of whether that requires an appeal to a higher court, or claiming wrongdoing under state law in Delaware’s Superior Court — instead of federal law as she did with the district court case.

“I don’t have litigation or trial experience, so this is new to me,” she said. “But I have a little more knowledge and understanding than some.”


Maggie Reynolds is a Report for America corps member and Spotlight Delaware reporter who covers rural communities in Delaware. Your donation to match our Report for America grant helps keep her writing stories like this one; please consider making a tax-deductible gift of any amount today by visiting https://spotlightdelaware.org/support/.

Maggie Reynolds is a reporter covering rural communities in Delaware through Report for America, a program aimed at addressing the growing crisis in local, independent news. She graduated from Middlebury...